Skip to main content

Research Repository

Advanced Search

Responsiveness of Objective, Disease-Specific, and Generic Outcome Measures in Patients With Chronic Low Back Pain: An Assessment for Improving, Stable, and Deteriorating Patients

Campbell, Helen; Rivero-Arias, Oliver; Johnston, Katharine; Gray, Alastair; Fairbank, Jeremy; Frost, Helen


Helen Campbell

Oliver Rivero-Arias

Katharine Johnston

Alastair Gray

Jeremy Fairbank

Helen Frost


Analysis of outcome data collected prospectively from 250 patients recruited to the UK Spine Stabilization Trial.
To compare the responsiveness of the Shuttle Walking Test (SWT), which is an objective outcome measure, with that of a disease-specific (the Oswestry Disability Index) and 2 generic (the EQ-5D and SF-36) instruments in patients with chronic low back pain (LBP).
Studies assessing the performance of subjective disease-specific and generic measures have increased in recent years, although there is a paucity of research reporting the responsiveness of objective measures in patients with LBP. The focus of investigation has been on responsiveness to improvements in LBP symptoms. For patients with deteriorating health, it remains largely unclear how outcome instruments perform.
Baseline and 12-month outcome data collected on 250 patients with chronic LBP recruited to the Spine Stabilization Trial were analyzed using traditional measures of responsiveness. Analyses were performed for 3 groups of patients: those who rated their health status as improved, deteriorated, and stable at 12 months.
The SWT was shown by all measures to be responsive to health improvement, although less so than other instruments. All instruments were able to detect small-to-moderate reductions in health. Instrument floor effects may be responsible for small SF-36 change scores recorded for deteriorating patients.
Although shown to be responsive, including the SWT alongside disease-specific and generic instruments is unlikely to add additional information. All instruments appear responsive to patient deterioration, however, further research for the SF-36 is required.

Journal Article Type Article
Publication Date 2006-04
Deposit Date Oct 19, 2017
Journal Spine
Print ISSN 0362-2436
Publisher Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins
Peer Reviewed Peer Reviewed
Volume 31
Issue 7
Pages 815-822
Keywords Orthopedics and Sports Medicine; Clinical Neurology
Public URL

Downloadable Citations