Skip to main content

Research Repository

Advanced Search

Encountering Misrecognition: Being Mistaken for Being Muslim

Hopkins, Peter; Botterill, Katherine; Sanghera, Gurchathen; Arshad, Rowena


Peter Hopkins

Katherine Botterill

Gurchathen Sanghera

Rowena Arshad


Exploring both debates about misrecognition and explorations of encounters, this paper focuses upon the experiences of ethnic and religious minority young people who are mistaken for being Muslim in Scotland. We explore experiences of encountering misrecognition, including young people's understandings of, and responses to, such encounters. Recognising how racism and religious discrimination operate to marginalise people – and how people manage and respond to this – is crucial in the struggle for social justice. Our focus is upon young people from a diversity of ethnic and religious minority groups who are growing up in urban, suburban and rural Scotland, 382 of whom participated in 45 focus groups and 224 interviews. We found that young Sikhs, Hindus and other South Asian young people as well as Black and Caribbean young people were regularly mistaken for being Muslim. These encounters tended to take place at school, in taxis, at the airport and in public spaces. Our analysis points to a dynamic set of interconnected issues shaping young people's experiences of misrecognition across a range of mediatised, geopoliticised and educational spaces. Geopolitical events and their representation in the media, the homogenisation of the South 'Asian' community and the lack of visibility offered to non-Muslim ethnic and religious minority groups all worked to construct our participants as 'Muslims'. Young people demonstrated agency and creativity in handling and responding to these encounters including: using humour; clarifying their religious affiliation; social withdrawal and ignoring the situation. Redressing misrecognition requires institutional change in order to ensure parity of participation in society.

Journal Article Type Article
Acceptance Date Nov 22, 2016
Online Publication Date Feb 28, 2017
Publication Date Jul 4, 2017
Deposit Date Dec 14, 2016
Publicly Available Date Aug 9, 2019
Journal Annals of the Association of American Geographers
Print ISSN 2469-4452
Electronic ISSN 2469-4460
Publisher Routledge
Peer Reviewed Peer Reviewed
Volume 107
Issue 4
Pages 934-948
Keywords Earth-Surface Processes; Geography, Planning and Development
Public URL
Contract Date Dec 14, 2016


Encountering Misrecognition: Being Mistaken for Being Muslim (560 Kb)

Publisher Licence URL

Copyright Statement
 P. Hopkins, K. Botterill, G. Sanghera, and R. Arshad.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (, which permits unrestricted
use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

Downloadable Citations